Pulitzer winning climate news.
facebook twitter subscribe
view counter

EagleFordProjectPreviewBlock

BloombergLegacyPreviewBlock

BusinessDeveloperAd



CleanBreakAdAmazon

Donate to InsideClimate News through our secure page on Network for Good.

New York Weighs 66,000 Comments on Pending Fracking Regulations

Department of Environmental Conservation will decide by end of year whether to continue a state-wide ban on hydraulic fracturing.

Apr 19, 2012
Opponenet of fracking

A four-year-old hydraulic fracturing study by New York's Department of Environmental Conservation has broken a state record: It has drawn more public reaction than any other issue in the agency's history.

Between September 2011 and January 2012, the DEC received more than 66,000 comments on the agency's revised draft supplemental generic environmental impact statement (SGEIS). That's in addition to the 13,000 comments it received in response to an earlier draft.

At stake is how—or if—New York will allow natural gas companies to use a combination of horizontal drilling and high-volume hydraulic fracturing known as fracking to develop the state's Marcellus Shale formation. The technology allows drilling companies to tap tightly bound gas deposits once considered too expensive to reach by pumping thousands, or sometimes millions, of gallons of water, sand and toxic chemicals underground to stimulate the flow of natural gas. Fracking has become controversial due to fears of water and air contamination. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has been studying whether drinking water in Pennsylvania was polluted by fracking.

New York's efforts to develop fracking regulations have attracted national attention because it is one of two states to place a hold on permits for high-volume hydraulic fracturing with horizontal drilling while it investigates the industry's impacts. A recent InsideClimate News story examined how one group of New York landowners hopes to circumvent the hold by fracking wells with liquid petroleum gas, which is primarily propane, rather than water. (Paragraph includes correction, 04/25/2012).

Maryland, the only other state to instate a delay in the high-volume, horizontal drilling process, recently launched its own study of the environmental and public health impacts of fracking. (Paragraph includes correction, 04/25/2012).

New York's DEC released the original draft SGEIS in September 2009 and published the revised draft SGEIS in September 2011. The final SGEIS and regulations are expected to be released together by the end of the year.

DEC spokeswoman Lisa King said the agency is reviewing all the comments it received during the last public comment period, which closed in January.

"Approximately 55 people from several divisions at DEC are involved with reviewing and preparing responses to comments. These include our minerals, water, air and lands & forests divisions," King told InsideClimate News in an email. "In addition, we are obtaining assistance from an environmental consulting firm."

King said the agency will consider the comments as it prepares a final SGEIS that will identify "all of the potential impacts to the environment associated with high-volume hydraulic fracturing and propos[e] mitigation measures to address those impacts."

According to New York environmental law, the DEC will have at least 10 days after the SGEIS and regulations are released to prepare a document that determines whether high-volume fracking will be allowed within the state. (Paragraph includes correction, 04/25/2012).

"If high-volume hydraulic fracturing moves forward in New York, the regulations would provide a regulatory framework to impose most of the mitigation measures in the SGEIS," King told InsideClimate News. "If high-volume hydraulic fracturing does not move forward…[those] regulations would not be necessary."

Some environmentalists believe the DEC will continue the permitting delay in New York. Others expect the DEC to approve high-volume fracking and are counting on the new regulations to provide effective protections. (Paragraph includes correction, 04/25/2012).

The DEC hasn't released the latest round of comments, but some industry and environmental groups have made their comments public. Here's a snapshot of what they've said:

Independent Oil and Gas Association of New York, an industry group

The proposed regulations and certain mitigation measures "are based upon unrealistic, worst-case scenarios that impose costly and time-consuming requirements…Without change, these proposals will render shale gas in New York non-competitive."

"…it does not appear that any consideration has been given to the timely processing of permit applications in New York State in order to lessen regulatory burdens, reduce staffing needs and promote natural gas development. The many sequential agency and intra-departmental reviews and coordination with river basin authorities…are too cumbersome and will not work in practice."

The proposed measures "require each operator to perform a 'green' frac analysis for each well permit application even though the industry has made great strides in greening frac fluid additives. This will lead to significant cost and delay, and there are no standards identified for review of the analysis."

Comment space is provided for respectful discourse. Please consult our comment policies for more information. We welcome your participation in civil and constructive discussions.