BERLIN, Germany—A decision 90 years ago by the people of Sacramento, Calif. to oust a private electric company and start a government-owned utility has been the unlikely inspiration for Berliners trying to wrest control of Germany's largest grid from a coal-fired utility.
While little known in America, the creation of Sacramento's Municipal Utility District was the model for a November referendum to give Berlin a municipal utility that would pump more clean energy into the grid. The 1923 vote in Sacramento helped the California city build a rare, green record—constructing the nation's first big solar plant, voting to shut down a nuclear reactor and approving a goal of slashing climate-changing emissions by 90 percent by 2050.
"Sacramento stopped nuclear with direct elections," said Stefan Taschner, spokesperson for Energietisch, the group behind the push to take over Berlin's grid. It provides the "best example of democratic control."
Berlin's referendum failed by a tiny margin—but it's not the end of the story. The contract to operate the grid expires at the end of next year, and the near-approval sent a strong message to the mayor and other officials that the city should buy the contract. The referendum needed 25 percent of Berlin's 2.5 million registered voters to pass; it missed that mark by less than 1 percent.
It seems unlikely that Berliners would look to Sacramento, or anywhere but their own country, for a model on how to build a greener grid—given that Germany is driving the world's most aggressive clean energy transformation. But Berlin has been largely left out of the shift, and activists here have been scrambling for tactics to limit influence of corporate fossil fuel interests. Less than 2 percent of the electricity produced in Berlin comes from renewables, compared to 25 percent in Germany overall.
The vast majority of Berlin's electricity is coal-fired and generated by energy giant Vattenfall, whose parent company won a contract in 1994 to operate the grid for 20 years.
Ending the privatization of energy is a major part of the Energiewende, Germany's plan to transition to renewables from fossil fuels and nuclear. A 2000 law gave citizens incentives to produce their own clean power and compete with utilities. As a result, 51 percent of the country's renewable power capacity is now owned by individuals who have built solar on rooftops and wind turbines on farms. That has left Germany's "Big Four" utilities, including Vattenfall, with just a sliver—6.5 percent—of this burgeoning sector.
The shift to city-owned utilities that are accountable to the public is happening quickly, with at least 72 new municipal utilities founded in Germany since 2005, according to a study by the Wuppertal Institute. The most significant is the industrial city of Hamburg, which approved a similar referendum to Berlin's last month.
Activists say the ultimate victory in the battle to "re-communalize" the grid, as Germans call it, would be to force change here in Berlin, Germany's capital and its largest city.
The United States has 2,006 public utilities, but most are tiny and, like Sacramento's, were created many decades ago during a short-lived wave of municipal takeovers sparked by anger over the rise of utility monopolies. Today, just 193 investor-owned utilities make up 60 percent of America's electricity market by revenue.
In recent years, people's desire for more clean power, concerns about global warming, rising electricity rates and anti-corporate sentiment have renewed citizen-led attempts to take over private electric companies—though it's nothing like what's happening Germany. Leading the charge is Boulder, Colo., where voters recently opened the path to a new city utility by taking the first step to end the city's relationship with energy giant Xcel Energy.
"I see a shift among larger cities toward looking at this notion of local control as a way of meeting climate and other renewable energy goals," said John Farrell, a researcher at the Minneapolis-based Institute for Local Self-Reliance. "Boulder started that movement. The work they did modeling the potential has lit a fire among other communities that had an interest before and didn't believe it was possible."
Berlin's Grid Battle
The headquarters of the Energietisch, which was founded two and a half years ago to promote the democratization and decentralization of energy, are in a building called the House of Democracy and Human Rights in Berlin.
Wearing jeans and a long ponytail, the spokesman, Taschner, ambled out of a backroom for an interview in the week after the vote. He looked tired after months of campaigning and a disappointing loss. But he was quick to note that the vote had helped change the way politicians look at energy and had brought his group's goals to the fore: more renewables, democratic control of the grid and affordable electricity.