‘No. I’m Not a Scientist’: Senators Press Trump Nominees on Climate Denial

Kathleen Hartnett White, who has called CO2 the "gas of life," and coal lobbyist Andrew Wheeler faced intense questioning over their positions on climate science.

Share this article

Kathleen Hartnett White arrived at Trump Tower last November while then-President-Elect Donald Trump and his transition team considered positions in the administration. Credit: Drew Angerer/Getty Images
Kathleen Hartnett White arrived at Trump Tower last November while then-President-Elect Donald Trump and his transition team considered positions in the administration. Credit: Drew Angerer/Getty Images

Share this article

Two of President Donald Trump’s most controversial nominees for environment posts—one a coal industry lobbyist, the other a former Texas environmental official who dubbed carbon dioxide the “gas of life”—got a grilling from Senate Democrats in a confirmation hearing on Wednesday.

During the hearing, Kathleen Hartnett White, a vocal supporter of the fossil fuel industry who has called the consensus on global warming a “kind of paganism,” and Andrew Wheeler, most recently a lobbyist for coal giant Murray Energy, responded to a battery of questions about climate change.

“You aren’t a scientist, are you?” Sen. Ben Cardin (D-Md.), asked White, during one exchange at Wednesday’s hearing, held by the Committee on Environment and Public Works.

“No. I’m not a scientist,” White responded. “But in my personal capacity, I have many questions that remain unanswered by current climate policy. I think we need to have more precise explanation of the human role and the natural role.”

Trump nominated White in October to head the Council on Environmental Quality, the top environmental job in the White House. Environmental groups have blasted the nomination from the outset, calling White an anti-science apologist for the fossil fuel industry. As a fellow of the Texas Public Policy Foundation, a conservative Austin-based think tank that has been funded by fossil fuel interests, including Exxon and the Koch brothers, she has many published writings and interviews expressing her views.

Trump nominated Wheeler to be second-in-command to EPA Administrator Scott Pruitt. Wheeler, a former EPA employee, was also a long-time staff member on the committee who worked for Sen. James Inhofe (R-Okla.), the famously climate-denying lawmaker who once brought a snowball to the Senate floor in an attempt to disprove global warming.

Tailpipes and “Pagans”

The committee’s Democrats on Wednesday fired away at White, questioning statements in her written work or radio interviews, one in which she told an interviewer that ozone isn’t harmful to human health “unless you put your mouth over the tailpipe of a car for eight hours.”

The panel’s top-ranking Democrat, Tom Carper of Delaware, noted that White has compared “people who believe that carbon pollution is causing climate change” to pagans and communists, and has said that efforts to reduce carbon pollution would lead to “poverty, socialism and concentration camps.”

Carper noted that international climate talks are underway in Bonn, Germany, and that Syria announced this week that it would sign on to the Paris Climate agreement, leaving the U.S. the only country that has expressed its intention to abandon the pact.

“Mrs. White, do you really believe that the views of all those countries’ leaders are properly compared to ideologues, pagans and communists?” Carper asked.

“No, I don’t,” White replied. “Those words or phrases were taken out of context.”

Lobbying for the Coal Industry

The panel’s Democrats pressed Wheeler about his lobbying work with Murray Energy and his knowledge of a three-page document, reportedly given to Pruitt by Bob Murray, the company’s CEO, earlier this year. Murray has said some of the instructions in the document—seen as a plan to effectively defang the agency—have already been implemented.

When asked by Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI), if he had seen the document, Wheeler said he had, but only “looked at it and handed it back” to Murray.  

“I think the American people are entitled to an EPA that is not following coal companies’ three-page plans, but is following wherever the best interests of the American people lead,” Whitehouse said.

Views on the Latest U.S. Climate Report

Sen. Jeff Merkley (D-Ore.) asked White and Wheeler about the Fourth National Climate Assessment—released last week by the Trump administration—pressing them on whether they accepted its findings.

The assessment presents the government’s most convincing evidence that fossil fuels and human activity are driving climate change.

“I view the report, really, as the product of the previous administration and not of this president,” White responded. “There are many differences, credible differences of opinion, among climate scientists.”

Wheeler said he did not reject the report’s findings, but added, “I’ve not read the report yet, and since it’s open for notice and comment at this point, I don’t think I would pre-judge.”

(The assessment consists of two volumes. The first volume, released in its final form last week, addresses the state of climate science and is no longer open for public comment.)

Praise from the GOP

The panel’s Republican members largely praised both nominees’ records and accused Democrats of overplaying climate change as an issue. White served a six-year term as chairman and commissioner of the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality starting in 2001, when she was appointed by then-Gov. Rick Perry, and she previously served on the Texas Water Development Board and has worked for the National Cattlemen’s Association. 

“All they want to talk about on the other side is global warming,” said Inhofe, the panel’s former chairperson, adding, “Everyone agrees the climate has and always will change. Historical evidence, scientific evidence, scriptural evidence—that’s a fact.”

The panel will review the nominees’ written responses to questions by the end of the month. A meeting to vote on the nominations has not been scheduled.  

Correction: This story was updated to correct the name of the senator who asked White about the National Climate Assessment.

Hi, and thanks for reading Inside Climate News. We hope you liked this article. While you were here, you may have noticed something that sets us apart from many other news outlets: our news is free to read.

That’s because Inside Climate News is a 501c3 nonprofit organization. We do not charge a subscription fee, lock our news behind a paywall, or clutter our website with ads. Instead, we give our news freely to you and to anyone who wants to learn about what’s happening to the climate.

We also share our news freely with scores of other media organizations around the country that can’t afford environmental journalism. We’ve built bureaus from coast to coast to get quality news to everyone who needs it. We collaborate, partner, and share.

Since day one, reader donations have funded every aspect of what we do. We opened our doors in 2007, and just six years later, earned a Pulitzer Prize for National Reporting. Now we run the oldest and largest dedicated climate newsroom in the country. We hold polluters accountable, expose environmental injustice, debunk misinformation, and inspire action.

It’s all possible because of readers like you. Today we’re asking you to invest in this work, our newsroom, and our continued growth. Help us keep reporting on the biggest crisis facing our planet and reach even more readers in more places. With your support, we can tell stories like the one you just read – stories that change hearts and minds and have seminal and enduring impact. Because of you, they’ll remain free for everyone, everywhere.

Please chip in now with whatever amount you can afford. It takes just a moment to give, and every gift makes a difference.

Thank you,

Share this article