Coal Mines Likely Drove China’s Recent Methane Emissions Rise, Study Says

A Chinese policy attempted to crack down on methane, but it proved ineffective, researchers say. They say mines may have tampered with emissions ahead of testing.

Coal miners in northern China. Credit: Str/AFP/Getty
Coal mines emit methane gas, a short-lived climate pollutant that is more potent than carbon dioxide at warming the planet over the short term but doesn't last as long in the atmosphere. Credit: Str/AFP/Getty

Share this article

Satellite data collected from 2010 to 2015 show that China’s methane emissions increased unabated during that period and that the increase was most likely driven by coal mining, according to a worrisome new report.

The increase in one of the most potent of greenhouse gases happened despite attempts by the Chinese government to rein in emissions, according to a study published Tuesday in the scientific journal Nature Communications. The regulations proved to be ineffective, perhaps because of loopholes or evasion.

The findings are significant because China is the world’s largest coal producer, and, on a unit-per-unit basis, methane released from mines warms the planet much more in the short term than carbon dioxide from burning coal.


We deliver climate news to your inbox like nobody else. Every day or once a week, our original stories and digest of the web's top headlines deliver the full story, for free.

“Methane emissions from China’s coal operations are roughly equivalent to 41 percent of CO2 emissions from U.S. power plants or 41 percent of CO2 emissions from transportation in a country like the United States,” said Scot Miller, the study’s lead author and an environmental health and engineer professor at Johns Hopkins University.

“Even small emissions reductions from a country like China could have an absolutely enormous impact on global greenhouse gases,” he said.

China’s Methane Crackdown

Recognizing the outsized influence that methane has on the climate, China set ambitious targets to capture and use methane from coal mining by 2015. (Methane, the main constituent of natural gas, accumulates in coal seams over millions of years as organic matter is slowly converted to coal.)

Beginning in 2006, China’s government required that all coal companies drain mines of methane prior to coal production and declared that coal mines cannot legally operate without such methane capture systems. A subsequent policy required that coal mines either use or flare the methane.

The findings shine a spotlight on both the powerful role methane plays in climate change and work that still needs to be done to mitigate global methane emissions.

“Methane is an incredibly overlooked short-lived climate pollutant, and China is not like Las Vegas; what happens there doesn’t stay there,” said Jennifer Turner, director of the China Environment Forum at the Wilson Center, a Washington, D.C.-based think tank. “They haven’t yet done enough to really capture the coal methane emissions.

Gaming an Exemption to the Rule?

Ranping Song, developing country climate action manager for the World Resources Institute, said the root of the problem lies in China’s continuing dependence on coal.

“Even if the Chinese government met its own methane capture and utilization target, the absolute amount would still increase because coal mine production increased,” Song said. “The most likely driving force is increased coal production.”

One reason government policies may have proven ineffective was an exemption from rules requiring companies to capture the methane and either flare or use the gas if methane made up less than 30 percent of the total gas emitted. The U.S. “EPA has anecdotal evidence that mine operators may be diluting drained gas to circumvent the requirement,” the study said.

Coal production in China plateaued and may have peaked toward the end of the study period, according to recent reports. Yet China still mines vast amounts of coal.

The study notes that there are a number of challenges that keep China from putting more captured methane to use, including the country’s lack of gas pipeline infrastructure and the remote, mountainous locations of many of its coal mines. That said, if the country were able to use all of the methane currently emitted from its mines, Miller estimates it could cover the electricity needs of 36 million people.

“There is a real potential for China to generate a significant amount of electricity or heat a relatively large number of homes from methane that otherwise leaks into the atmosphere,” Miller said.