Data Center Impact Hotly Contested in Federal Permitting Fight

The bipartisan bill would force AI companies to pay their electric grid costs, but foes fear the measure will accelerate the boom and lock in Trump administration decisions on federal land.

Share This Article

Transmission lines run next to a data center development site in Red Oak, Texas, on June 24. Credit: Angela Piazza/The Dallas Morning News via Getty Images
Transmission lines run next to a data center development site in Red Oak, Texas, on June 24. Credit: Angela Piazza/The Dallas Morning News via Getty Images

Share This Article

Data centers have become a key focus of the acrimonious debate over the bill Senate leaders hope to pass this week to overhaul the federal permitting process.

Progress on the measure ground to a halt Thursday in part over a fight to add a provision that would ban data centers on federal lands. President Donald Trump’s administration has expressed interest in using public lands for that purpose.

Authors of the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, or BAAJA, maintain that the bill would not change the law on the siting of data centers. On the contrary, it includes provisions that would mark Congress’ first demands on artificial intelligence facility developers, requiring them to pay costs that until now have been foisted on electricity ratepayers. Supporters say it would mean a $35 billion infusion into the electric grid, intended to ease consumer costs.

Newsletters

We deliver climate news to your inbox like nobody else. Every day or once a week, our original stories and digest of the web’s top headlines deliver the full story, for free.

But opponents of the sprawling 495-page legislation argue that its overall effect would be to speed data center development, even though few data centers require federal permits. That’s because all data centers need copious amounts of energy, and the bill would make it easier to build pipelines, mines, transmission lines and power plants. The largest driver of demand for this new energy infrastructure in the United States is the artificial intelligence build-out, and public anger over data centers helped propel Democrats to victory in the midterm elections.

“This bill doesn’t just roll out the red carpet for data center developers, it puts them on a greased-up slide into towns across America,” said Sen. Edward Markey (D-Mass.) on the Senate floor.

With new research out this week showing that U.S. data centers are churning out greenhouse gas emissions far beyond previous estimates, Markey and other BAAJA foes warn that the legislation would accelerate climate pollution, spur a surge in natural gas prices that could erase any electricity cost savings and lock in decisions the Trump administration is eager to make to site data centers on Western public lands.

Trump and Republicans solidly support BAAJA, with Sen. Alan Armstrong (R-Okla.), former chief executive of the gas pipeline giant Williams Cos., even citing its potential to spur data center development as a selling point. 

But Democrats are bitterly divided. Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.) and Sen. Martin Heinrich (D-Nev.), who negotiated the permitting deal with Republicans, argue that far from driving new emissions, the bill will supercharge a clean energy transition by removing the barriers that have held back solar, wind and battery storage. On Wednesday night, after some Democratic support for BAAJA eroded, leaving them only six votes from losing the 60 needed for passage in the Senate, the pair posted a video on X to “do a little myth-busting,” in Whitehouse’s words.

“I don’t know that there are two Senators who care more about protecting the environment than we do,” Whitehouse said. The bill doesn’t lower standards, but sets deadlines and “lets the clean energy that is going to protect the environment get built,” he said.

The battle this week in the Senate, set to move soon to the House, is being waged between Democrats like Whitehouse and Heinrich, who have faith that cheaper clean energy will win out, and opponents like Markey who fear that fossil fuels will flood the zone that BAAJA opens up. 

The natural gas industry is winning already, they argue, because of its success in promoting itself as the always-on, easily deployable and abundant solution to feed the data center industry’s voracious energy appetite.

Ratepayer Protection, But Looming Gas Trouble

The first peer-reviewed research measuring big data center carbon emissions in the United States showed that the problem is two to three times larger than previous estimates would suggest. So-called “hyperscale” facilities, the 400 largest and most powerful data centers in the United States, are together responsible for emitting 25.7 million metric tons of carbon dioxide annually, according to the study published Monday in Nature Sustainability by researchers at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health and the Harvard Data Science Initiative. That’s similar to the CO2 emissions of Bolivia and larger than those of more than 120 countries.

The Harvard researchers found that roughly 54 percent of the electricity powering the hyperscale data centers was generated by fossil fuels—38 percent by natural gas and 15 percent by coal. 

Clean energy industry advocates who support BAAJA say the legislation would change that mix, expanding electricity transmission and getting renewable energy projects that have been stuck in the interconnection queue hooked up to the grid.

“One of the measures we wanted to insist upon as we designed this bill was major emissions reductions, and it produces gigaton-scale carbon emissions reduction,” Whitehouse said in the Wednesday video posted on X. 

From left: Sen. Mike Lee (R-Utah), Sen. Shelley Moore Capito (R-W.Va.), Sen. Martin Heinrich (D-N.M.) and Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.) hold a news conference on the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act in the U.S. Capitol on Sept. 30 . Credit: Bill Clark/CQ-Roll Call via Getty Images
From left: Sen. Mike Lee (R-Utah), Sen. Shelley Moore Capito (R-W.Va.), Sen. Martin Heinrich (D-N.M.) and Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.) hold a news conference on the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act in the U.S. Capitol on Sept. 30 . Credit: Bill Clark/CQ-Roll Call via Getty Images

Analysts at Rhodium Group estimated that BAAJA’s removal of barriers to the grid interconnection process would indeed produce such large net economy-wide greenhouse gas reductions, even though the bill also reduces the cost and accelerates the pace of building natural gas pipelines.

Another key selling point of the bill has been that it would save consumers money by enacting an enhanced version of the Ratepayer Protection Pledge that Trump promoted at the White House earlier this year and that the House passed 417-3 in September.

Usually, utilities spread the cost of grid upgrades among all customers, but under BAAJA, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission would write new rules to ensure all data centers—new and old—are charged both for upgrades they require as well as for their use of the existing grid. The consulting firm Grid Strategies estimates the data center industry would pay an additional $35 billion in electric transmission costs (for a total $55 billion) over the next 10 years.

“The day of data center freeloading ends when this bill passes,” Whitehouse said.

But some environmental groups have raised concerns that the bill’s authors may have inserted a significant loophole this week by exempting data centers that are used primarily for internet or cable. And BAAJA critics say the electric grid is only one of the ways that data centers are driving up both carbon emissions and energy costs. The AI industry is increasingly building on-site power plants, which could ramp up demand and the cost of natural gas while they generate carbon emissions far beyond those captured by the Harvard study of grid-connected data centers.

A recent survey by McKinsey & Co. found 60 percent of North American data center players now plan to deploy permanent power plants on site, either to speed past the long process of connecting to the grid or to provide permanent back-up power. And amid the Trump administration’s retreat from U.S. climate action, the vast majority of that on-site power is to be fueled by natural gas.

It’s “an unprecedented development for the modern U.S. power system,” the McKinsey report said. 

About 100 gigawatts of gas-burning capacity is planned at data centers across the country, according to BloombergNEF, equivalent to 18 percent of existing U.S. natural gas power plant capacity. A more recent analysis by the Better Data Center Project and Earthjustice puts the figure at 177 gigawatts. 

If all the planned projects are built, the Earthjustice study said nine of the 10 largest power plants in the United States will be on-site for data centers.

“The bill is not addressing that at all,” said Meg Slattery, staff scientist at Earthjustice. “And the models that model the emissions impacts of the bill do not account for behind-the-meter generation.”

Anthropic, which launched its record-breaking $81.3 billion initial public offering Thursday as the Senate was wrangling over BAAJA, identified the scramble for natural gas as one of its main business risks in the prospectus for investors it released early this month.

“As data center operators increasingly rely on natural gas-fired generation … we expect increased competition among users for the same natural gas supply and pipeline capacity” in areas where on-site power plants are feasible, said Anthropic, creator of the AI product Claude. “This competition could drive up the price of natural gas in such areas.”

This story is funded by readers like you.

Our nonprofit newsroom provides award-winning climate coverage free of charge and advertising. We rely on donations from readers like you to keep going. Please donate now to support our work.

Donate Now

The Data Center Coalition, which includes Microsoft, Google, Amazon and other big players in the tech industry, said it is still reviewing the details of the latest version of BAAJA. Michele Nellenbach, the group’s vice president of federal affairs, said its members are doing their part to address affordability and economic growth by investing hundreds of billions of dollars in the U.S. economy annually.

“At a time when the cost of living is top of mind for many, data centers can play a critical role in advancing affordability for Americans,” she said in an emailed statement. “Data centers create well-paying jobs, generate substantial tax revenue, advance innovation, can lower electricity rates for other ratepayers, and deliver significant economic investment and opportunity to local communities.”

An Effort to Amend or Delay

There is no shortage of ideas on how BAAJA or separate legislation could address the energy costs, climate pollution and other impacts of data centers.

Jeffrey Rissman and Eric Gimon of the nonpartisan research firm Energy Innovation have argued for a “Bring Your Own Clean Energy Mandate” for data centers. It would not only reduce demand on the natural gas system, it would reduce soot and noise from the facilities, “ensuring the data centers powering the AI revolution don’t come at the expense of Americans’ wallets, health and well-being,” they wrote. Sonia Aggarwal, the CEO of Energy Innovation, more recently wrote that Congress should design a gas customer protection plan analogous to the electric ratepayer protection plan that is already in BAAJA.

An idea that Sen. Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) pushed this week as a potential BAAJA amendment was a ban on data centers on federal land. The Trump administration already has approved the siting of one such project, the Townsite Data Center, on 88.5 acres managed by the Bureau of Land Management in Nevada near land the company has developed for solar energy. 

The Center for Western Priorities says BLM is considering at least 35 active data-center-related applications, covering more than 24,000 acres in six Western states. One such project is reportedly being planned for 100 acres of BLM land in the eastern part of Wyden’s state, Oregon.

Heinrich maintains that BAAJA does nothing to make it easier to site data centers, on or off federal land. But the legislation would severely limit the kinds of lawsuits typically used to stop such projects. (One such challenge is underway against the Townsite project, brought by Boulder City, Nevada, and environmental groups.) 

BAAJA would amend the National Environmental Policy Act to take away federal judges’ authority to halt or pause a project because the federal government has conducted an inadequate environmental review. Instead, projects on federal land would be allowed to proceed while environmental review is underway. Retired federal judge David Tatel, who heard many NEPA cases over a 30-year career on the bench, recently wrote that BAAJA would reduce the environmental law to “a mere husk.”

On Thursday morning, Wyden posted on X that Republican leaders were blocking a floor vote on his proposal. Referring to one of the bill’s co-authors, Republican Mike Lee of Utah, chairman of the Senate Energy Committee, Wyden wrote, “BAAJA achieves Mike Lee’s fever dream of giving away your public lands to tech giants.”

Democratic foes of BAAJA want to put a hold on the legislation until January. They argue they would then have clout to negotiate a better deal for the environment and affordability that addresses the impact of the estimated $10.3 trillion data center boom, which analysts at the Brookings Institution calculate is larger relative to the U.S. economy than the build-out of the railroads, highways or electrification. 

Proponents fear, however, they may not get a bill as beneficial as BAAJA is for clean energy that Trump will sign. “Grab the bird in the hand,” Whitehouse said. “If there’s things to improve, we have the next Congress to improve them.”

That might not be easy. As long as the Senate maintains its filibuster rules, the same math that applies to BAAJA will apply to any legislation Democrats advance next year. It will need either 60 votes in the Senate and the president’s signature, or two-thirds of both the House and Senate to override Trump. In other words, if Congress hopes either to break the logjam holding back clean energy or rein in the spread of data centers, at least the first word of BAAJA—“bipartisan”—will be a must.

About This Story

Perhaps you noticed: This story, like all the news we publish, is free to read. That’s because Inside Climate News is a 501c3 nonprofit organization. We do not charge a subscription fee, lock our news behind a paywall, or clutter our website with ads. We make our news on climate and the environment freely available to you and anyone who wants it.

That’s not all. We also share our news for free with scores of other media organizations around the country. Many of them can’t afford to do environmental journalism of their own. We’ve built bureaus from coast to coast to report local stories, collaborate with local newsrooms and co-publish articles so that this vital work is shared as widely as possible.

Two of us launched ICN in 2007. Six years later we earned a Pulitzer Prize for National Reporting, and now we run the oldest and largest dedicated climate newsroom in the nation. We tell the story in all its complexity. We hold polluters accountable. We expose environmental injustice. We debunk misinformation. We scrutinize solutions and inspire action.

Donations from readers like you fund every aspect of what we do. If you don’t already, will you support our ongoing work, our reporting on the biggest crisis facing our planet, and help us reach even more readers in more places?

Please take a moment to make a tax-deductible donation. Every one of them makes a difference.

Thank you,

Share This Article