ACORE Launches Effort to Counter Partisan Attacks on Clean Energy

Retired Vice Adm. Dennis McGinn: 'We decided that we're not going to just stand by and be defensive.'

Retired Vice Adm. Dennis McGinn, president and CEO of the American Council on Re
Retired Vice Adm. Dennis McGinn, president and CEO of the American Council on Renewable Energy (ACORE)

Share this article

The renewable energy industry’s main trade group has officially come out swinging against the political backlash and negative press its members have endured since solar manufacturer Solyndra went bankrupt last year.

“We decided that we’re not going to just stand by and be defensive … in the face of this overwhelming onslaught of misinformation,” said Retired Vice Adm. Dennis McGinn, president and CEO of the American Council on Renewable Energy (ACORE), at the group’s two-day annual meeting. 

ACORE’s 600-plus members represent billions of dollars in renewable energy business, and are involved in more than 80 percent of the nation’s existing and contracted clean energy projects, the group says.

Fossil-fuel interests and clean energy opponents in Washington have “dominated the conversation [on renewables] through misrepresentation, exaggeration, distraction and millions and millions of dollars in advertising,” McGinn, a 66-year-old Navy veteran and national security strategist, told an audience of hundreds of renewable energy and finance leaders last week.

“No more. We can no longer allow America’s energy debate to be one-sided to the detriment of our nation,” he declared in the ballroom of the luxurious Waldorf-Astoria Hotel. 

The goal now is to hammer home the “impressive growth rates … of new clean energy generation, billions of dollars in investments and a multitude of jobs.”

McGinn’s statements represent the first time that the doggedly nonpartisan and business-minded group has taken such a firm stand to protect the image of its industries. ACORE told InsideClimate News it reached its decision after members repeatedly complained that every recent hiccup or bad apple was being blown out of proportion.

The most well-known of these was Solyndra, recipient of a $535 million federal loan guarantee under the Obama administration. After the solar panel maker went bankrupt last summer and fired 1,861 people, many Republicans used it as a cudgel against taxpayer-supported clean energy economy programs. Missed sales targets from electric car makers were also cast as a sign of imminent failure for green vehicles, among other things.

The negative publicity “threatens the market momentum that we’ve achieved and the success to date,” McGinn said.

Injecting positive stories into the U.S. renewable energy debate will not be easy.

There’s a “degree of hostility towards the clean energy agenda that I don’t recall having seen in my 25 years working in the space,” said Daniel Esty, commissioner of Connecticut’s Department of Energy & Environmental Protection and a former professor of environmental law at Yale University, in a keynote address at ACORE’s conference. 

Over the past year, congressional Republicans have moved to the right on clean energy and climate change issues, and fossil-fuel backers continue to throw money into advertising on behalf of GOP candidates.

Americans for Prosperity (AFP), a conservative group founded and funded by oil industry interests, including billionaire oil executives Charles and David Koch, has spent $8.4 million since November to run one-minute spots on T.V. and on social media sites accusing Obama of cronyism with Solyndra. The ads ran in key swing states like Iowa, Michigan, North Carolina, Ohio, Virginia and Wisconsin.

Since its first Solyndra ad blitz, AFP has spent $20 million on anti-Obama ad buys and expects to spend a total of $100 million by November, the Los Angeles Times reported last week. The Koch brothers’ network will funnel $400 million into a handful of conservative groups this election season, Politico reported in May.

The 11-year-old ACORE represents companies from across the clean technology spectrum—from solar, wind and energy efficiency to biofuels and electric cars. Its members include solar developers BrightSource Energy and SolarCity, banking giant Goldman Sachs and utility Duke Energy.

The group raised $3.2 million from member dues, grants and fundraising efforts in 2010, the latest data available.

A Space to Respond

To support its advocacy efforts, ACORE launched a website and Twitter account last week called and @EnergyFactCheck. “We will be carrying the fantastic story about renewable energy and our industry to the media, policymakers and to the public,” McGinn told the Waldorf-Astoria audience.

On the sidelines of the conference, McGinn told InsideClimate News that the highly politicized story of Solyndra “wasn’t the catalyst for this site,” though he did say it was “a big cause for the misinformation” around renewable energy. (When asked his political affiliation, McGinn said he is “fiercely independent.”)

“The idea is to try to have much a faster response” to “the myths that are associated with renewable energy—it’s too expensive, it will never scale up, it’s totally government dependent … and on and on,” he said. has been in the works since last fall. ACORE led the development of the site with help from outside contractors, including The Glover Park Group, a Democrat-leaning communications consulting firm. Glover Park’s founders previously served as officials in the Clinton administration and as campaign staff for former Vice President Al Gore’s presidential bid in 2000.

ACORE will collaborate with nearly 20 different renewable energy trade associations and advocates on the site’s upkeep. Staff will update it with the latest data from the trade groups, government agencies, energy labs and private financial analysts. Reporters, policymakers and curious citizens can also write to the site’s e-mail address to get data not listed on the site.

The site is divided into five sections. The first, called “The Fact Check,” reads like a question-and-answer form. Each negative claim about the renewables industry is paired with a rebuttal.

Another section, “Energy Issues,” provides statistics, such as renewable energy system costs, new project developments and job creation. The site’s “Energy Library” is a list of about a year and a half’s worth of industry reports and select independent studies. 

The Twitter account, which has 364 followers so far, is also run by ACORE. The group will tweet figures and will intervene in conversations when it sees inaccurate claims being made against renewables.

At the conference, ACORE members seemed enthusiastic about the idea.

“I think it certainly makes sense that the industry provide a set of clear statements and clear responses to some of the charges and incorrect assumptions which are made regarding renewable energy as a whole,” said Michael Whalen, chief financial officer of SolarReserve, a Santa Monica, Calif.-based solar developer.

SolarReserve saw its own share of bad press last fall after the Energy Department finalized a $737 million loan guarantee for the firm’s Crescent Dunes solar thermal power plant in Nevada.

The announcement came a month after Solyndra’s bankruptcy. Word soon got out that one of Solyndra’s investors, George Kaiser, an oil executive and an Obama campaign contributor, was also an investor in SolarReserve, sparking accusations that Obama showed political favoritism when granting that loan, too.

Whalen said the coverage didn’t harm his company, but he expressed frustration at what he sees as misperceptions about solar power’s limitations.

“We’d love to have rebuttal space,” he said.